N’ont-ils pas vu les oiseaux assujettis [au vol] dans l’atmosphère du ciel sans que rien ne les retienne en dehors d’Allah ? Il y a vraiment là des preuves pour des gens qui croient.
Tafsirs
Niveaux
Leçons
Réflexions
Réponses
Qiraat
Hadith
Conjoncture:
ىروا
Lecteurs
Abū Jaʿfar
Ibn ʿĀmir
Nāfiʿ
Ḥamzah
Ibn Kathīr
Khalaf
Abū ʿAmr
al-Kisāʾī
Yaʿqūb
ʿĀṣim
Lectures:
يَرَوْا
a-lam yaraw
“Have they not seen”
This reading speaks of the unbelievers in the third person, as in numerous places in this passage.
تَرَوْا
a-lam taraw
"Have you not seen"
This reading addresses the people directly, as in the immediate context.
Explication:
These readings amount to the same meaning [al-Mahdawi].
He has revealed to you ˹O Prophet˺ the Book in truth, confirming what came before it, as He revealed the Torah and the Gospel
Explication:
These readings amount to the same meaning [al-Mahdawi].